Richard Bowen

  • Home
  • About
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Media/Press
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • +1-214-604-5492

March 29, 2018 By Richard Bowen

Do Financial Regulations Actually Work Or Are We Kidding Ourselves!?

In the last 10 years, the collapse of so many of our financial institutions and the subsequent bailouts prompted the passing  of regulations that many hoped would cure further bank and corporate mishaps and prevent scandals and fraud.

Yet did they? An article by three professors, Luzi Hail, PhD., the Wharton School, Ahmed Tahoun, PhD.,  the London Business School, and Clare Wang, PhD., the Tippy College of Business at U of Iowa, for the Institute for New Economic Thinking makes a provocative case that, in fact, regulations prompt more misbehavior.

In the article, “How Well Does Financial Regulation Work?” – What 200 Years of Government Interventions in Financial Markets Can Tell Us,” the authors state, “financial crises have long been a feature of our system. There’s a discernible pattern: Scandals are followed by regulation, only for a new set of scandals to emerge thereafter. They ask, can the cycle can be broken?”

They mention  former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volker’s comments  to the members of the Economic  Club of New York on April 8, 2008, in which he pointed out  that Bears Sterns rescue by JP Morgan Chase and the Fed’s actions “implied promise of similar action in times of future turmoil.”

Recall that it was the Fed’s intervention as “the start of a cycle of institutional collapses and bailouts that defined the 2008 financial crisis.” They quote Mr. Volker that such crises have in fact been a “recurrent feature of free and open capital markets” and that “any return to heavily regulated, bank-dominated, nationally insulated markets is pure nostalgia.”

The authors ask a very disturbing question: has anything been learned from our most recent financial crisis and, further, given the long history of government intervention in financial markets, have  financial regulations anywhere at any time been truly effective at curbing “mishaps?”

Their conclusion, as noted in their extensive published study: “It appears that regulations do not curb corporate misconduct, but today’s regulations predict an increase, rather than a decrease, in future corporate scandals. And the results cast doubt on the effectiveness of regulation from a public interest view.” 

They point-blank ask readers to consider, “are regulatory interventions in financial markets delayed reactions to market failures, or can regulators pre-empt corporate misbehavior? Given the high economic and social costs associated with corporate scandals, and the substantial resources countries dedicate to preventing such misconduct, the answer to this question is of utmost importance”. 

The author’s research is extensive, following a series of corporate scandals and regulations across 26 countries from the 1800s to 2015.They examined accounting and other corporate scandals and the rules that dealt with accounting regulations and investor protection. In the U.S alone, they identified 230 episodes of corporate scandals and 48 relevant regulatory initiatives.

You’d think that effective regulations would prevent corporate misbehavior in the first place and, if not, at least correct mishaps and transgressions; however, such does not appear to be the case. What they found suggests that the evolution of financial markets plays a key role in shaping both corporate misbehaviors and regulatory action here and abroad. The bottom line: they found that no real evidence exists that regulations can actually curb corporate misconduct.

Instead, regulations may, in fact, be a strong predictor of future fraudulent behaviors — because firms are quick to adapt to the new rules and move their activities to unregulated areas, regulators rely on explicitly  laid-out rules to be able to identify and prosecute corporate wrong doing or because  the new regulations have unintended consequences.

In an earlier article late last year the same authors ask: Can regulators proactively pre-empt corporate wrongdoing before it occurs? And do they detect and rectify actual misbehavior in a timely and persistent manner? They point out:

(i)
Corporate scandals are an antecedent to regulation over long stretches of time, suggesting that regulators are typically less flexible and informed than firms.
(ii) Regulation is positively related to the incidence of future scandals, suggesting that regulators are not fully effective, that explicit rules are required to identify scandalous corporate actions, or that new regulations have unintended consequences.
(iii) There exist systematic differences in these lead-lag relations across countries and over time suggesting that the effectiveness of regulation is shaped by fundamental country characteristics like market development and legal tradition.

Looks like a chicken-egg proposition, scandals are followed by regulations only for a new set of scandals to break out which leads to more regulations! In a Naked Capitalism post, Yves Smith says, “this post reaches an important but disheartening conclusion, that financial regulation often does not work because it is reactive and clever financial players find ways to skirt regulations.”

Ms. Smith advocates that “finance is best kept firmly leashed and collared…we need a systematic approach to regulations rather than one off moves.” But, she says, “the notion that financiers can safely be left to their own  devices is so firmly ingrained that that is not going to happen anytime soon.”

Why did Willie Sutton rob banks? Because that’s where the money is!

I’m reminded of the recent article I wrote regarding Chairman of the Senate Banking Committee Chairman Senator Mike Crapo’s (R-ID) proposal of a major rollback of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, The Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act. and the workaround the larger banks are already trying in order to get around its restrictions! Wall Street has already whittled down the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation by a thousand cuts. 

So, if regulators are less flexible than the companies they are attempting to regulate and they react to, rather than prevent corporate misbehavior, well what’s the point? If there is no real evidence that regulations curb corporate misconduct and the opposite is, in fact, the case, how do we come up with a solution?

On Wall Street, amongst regulators, government agencies and the attorneys who go to bat for the corporate wrongdoers, who is going to take a stand when they know they will need their cronies’ approval and approbation in their next position? The practice of Wall Street executives cashing out early and thus being rewarded when they take government jobs surely prevents enforcing of regulations.

Well, if you’re coming back to play on Wall Street, you sure don’t want to alienate your banking buddies by prosecuting them for fraud and intentional wrongdoing. Heaven forbid you would hold them accountable!

You don’t put your friends and colleagues in jail, you just circumvent the rules. My hat’s off to the authors for their extensive research. Disheartening? Yes. Enlightening? Yes, yet are regulations of any kind futile? Or, do we have to have checks and balances to keep some semblance of ethics and the right path in place?

Related Posts

Robin Hood and the Too Big To Fail! Is He Too Late to Help on the Crapo Bill?
The Bank Foxes are Guarding the SEC Chicken Coop!
Why Are Wall Street Bankers Taking Government Jobs?
The Wall Street Merry-Go-Round Revolves Again!

Finally! There’s a Corporate Ethics Revolution Going On - PwC CEO Survey Results
What do Edward Snowden, Frank Serpico, Daniel Ellsberg, and Richard Bowen Have in Common?
Ethics on your mind? Subscribe to my ezine to get my latest article delivered right to your inbox. Click Here to Subscribe

Richard Bowen is widely known as the Citigroup whistleblower. As Business Chief Underwriter for Citigroup during the housing bubble financial crisis meltdown, he repeatedly warned Citi executive management and the board about fraudulent behavior within the organization. The company certified poor mortgages as quality mortgages and sold them to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and other investors.

Related Posts

  • A Tribute to Ross PerotA Tribute to Ross Perot
  • Everybody Lies!Everybody Lies!
  • Bank Whistleblowers United D.C. Press Conference Hits a Home Run!Bank Whistleblowers United D.C. Press Conference Hits a Home Run!
  • The 2nd NCPA Financial Crisis Initiative kicks off with the Honorable Jeb Hensarling (R-TX)The 2nd NCPA Financial Crisis Initiative kicks off with the Honorable Jeb Hensarling (R-TX)

What People Are Saying About Richard M. Bowen

William D. Cohan"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst."

~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
2017-06-30T10:08:59-05:00
"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst." ~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/2556/

Eileen McDonnell"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger."

~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
2015-02-13T19:51:19-06:00
"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger." ~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/711/

Ben Stein"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero."

~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
2015-02-13T19:50:26-06:00
"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero." ~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/712/

Jim Farrell"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership."

~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
2014-12-28T19:48:17-06:00
"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership." ~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/532/

Dennis McCuistion"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years."

~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
2014-12-28T19:48:06-06:00
"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years." ~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/533/

Betty Garrett"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!"

~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
2014-12-28T19:47:50-06:00
"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!" ~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/531/

fred-timmons"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences."

~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
2014-12-28T19:47:22-06:00
"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences." ~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/530/

Presentation Topics

Playing for High Stakes: The Principles and Practice of Ethical Leadership

Dark Citi: The Story of a Whistleblower

Want to Hire Richard?

Watch Richard

See What Clients are Saying

About Richard

Recent Posts

  • Warmest thoughts and best wishes for a wonderful and safe holiday
  • Thanksgiving 2020
  • Pausing For A While
  • The world is in crisis
  • Relationships Count

Categories

  • Business Ethics
  • Congress
  • Corporate Debt
  • Corruption
  • Ethical Leadership
  • Financial Crime
  • Financial Crisis
  • Financial Crisis of 2008
  • Holiday
  • International
  • Mortgage Lending
  • Mortgage Meltdown
  • Relationships
  • Texas Politics
  • The Fed
  • Too Big To Fail
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Wall Street
  • Whistle Blowers

About Richard

Now an ethical leadership speaker, Richard Bowen was Citigroup's Business Chief Underwriter during the housing bubble.

Read more

Connect with Richard

  Facebook   Twitter   Linked   Google Plus   YouTube

Contact Us

Phone: +1-214-604-5492

Email: Richard@RichardMBowen.com

Contact Richard
Google+

Copyright 2019© 2021 · Richard M. Bowen | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

SAVE & ACCEPT
X
Sign up to receive my blog posts via email!
Subscribe >>