Richard Bowen

  • Home
  • About
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Media/Press
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • +1-214-604-5492

October 7, 2021 By Richard Bowen

Citigroup to Facebook, it’s about power

Side-by-side image with Frances Haugen's 60 MInutes interview on the left and Richard M. Bowen's 60 Minutes interview on the right.
Left: Frances Haugen sits down with 60 Minutes in 2021 to discuss whistleblowing at Facebook.
Right: Richard M. Bowen sits down with 60 Minutes in 2011 to discuss whistleblowing at Citigroup.

On Sunday, October 3rd, I saw the 60 Minutes story about Frances Haugen, the Facebook whistleblower. I was absolutely blown away in so many different aspects. I was thrown back to 2011 when I did a 60 Minutes story based upon my whistleblowing at Citigroup.

While our stories come from different industries, both situations involve manipulating people. All the similarities between our stories come down to one: Powerful people exploited those who lacked power in order to increase personal gain.

Frances Haugen was concerned about Facebook’s corporate leadership, which embraced a culture that encouraged potentially harmful actions because those actions were more profitable for the company. Facebook had an algorithm that knew the types of content the user was attracted to or had high interaction and thus selected more of the same content so that the user would interface with Facebook longer. Why would giving people what they want be a bad thing, though? If it’s what they want, then they’ll be happy.

But engagement is not always about what people want. It’s what they engage with. Engagement goes beyond likes. There is a system weighing every interaction to a post, and each interaction – likes, dislikes, cares, comments, everything – plays into the engagement number. Increased engagement means people spend more time on the platform. Extended time on the platform increases revenue for the company, so getting an emotional response is good for the bottom line. And, as Haugen said in her interview, “It’s easier to inspire people to anger than it is to other emotions.”

Thus, those that had previously either sought out or engaged with hateful and divisive content were given much more hateful and divisive content, which creates an emotional response, and more engagement. The cycle continues.

This cycle didn’t stop with Facebook. The company also owns Instagram, which uses similar methods. Many younger girls sought specific topics, such as eating disorders, and were thus given more of that content, reinforcing eating disorders and even thoughts of suicide.

Internal documents show that not only did the company know what was happening, but they also continued working to ensure this would continue. To the point of turning off safety systems that had blocked misinformation in 2020.

In a response on Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg said, “The argument that we deliberately push content that makes people angry for profit is deeply illogical. We make money from ads, and advertisers consistently tell us they don’t want their ads next to harmful or angry content. And I don’t know any tech company that sets out to build products that make people angry or depressed. The moral, business and product incentives all point in the opposite direction.”

He goes on to say that they “have advocated for updated internet regulations for several years now. I have testified in Congress multiple times and asked them to update these regulations. I’ve written op-eds outlining the areas of regulation we think are most important related to elections, harmful content, privacy, and competition.”

Zuckerberg’s saying the internet needs oversight is a good attempt at passing the buck. It’s a “the game let me do it” kind of response that puts the blame on the people who created the system, except, in this case, he is that person. As the majority stakeholder, he is the final recipient of the passed buck.

Of course he wants to divert blame. He needs his company to look good. Jumping out with an admission would not maintain the user numbers the company needs to remain profitable.

This is similar to what Citigroup had to say about my allegations.

I saw management ignoring their own internal warnings about selling mortgages and mortgage-backed securities to investors. Citi was giving their representations to the purchasers of these securities that even though the mortgages were originated by other banks and mortgage companies, they followed Citigroup’s own mortgage lending policies. As I issued many high-level warnings throughout the company that these representations were false, the business model of selling these defective mortgages was exceptionally profitable, throwing off significant incentive compensation to all management, and thus the company increased dramatically the selling of the billions of dollars of defective mortgages to make more profit. I kept issuing warnings for eighteen months and finally sent a detailed warning to Robert Rubin, Chairman of the Board, and the other executive officers, when I was stripped of my responsibilities and told not to come back to the bank.

Frances Haugen testified before Congress on Monday, telling them about her findings and sharing documents she took from the company. And she received enthusiastic and positive responses from Congress that additional regulation was needed to protect the public from Facebook’s mismanagement.

I also testified before the SEC in 2008 and the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (FCIC) in 2010 and, once again, the circumstances were somewhat different. The harm that Citigroup did was primarily related to their investors, including the many pension funds who purchased their securities, not the billions of people worldwide that deal with Facebook, with both the SEC and the FCIC burying my testimony and trying to hide it from public scrutiny. And no one was held accountable and there was no real attempt to further regulate these banking practices.

I have been where Haugen is. I have endured what she will likely endure, if she hasn’t already. Being labeled as a “disgruntled employee,” industry backlash, and questionable career stability are only a few of the rewards we whistleblowers get for shining light on wrongdoing.

Even with protections, whistleblowers suffer for standing up for what is right. Some of us go on to speak about our experiences, others teach, and still others change professions altogether. The one thing that most of us have in common is a moment in which we had to make a choice between what is convenient – going along to get along – and what our ethical codes tell us is right – shining a light on unethical behavior.

Both Haugen’s and my experiences boil down to the powerful few exploiting those without power. And powerful people will always try to exploit the powerless for the sake of profit. As someone said about divisive content, it’s just human nature. But will we, as a society, continue to allow the powerful few to exploit the masses? How long will we allow this to continue?

Is there a lesson in the Holmes verdict?
The Con Docuseries More Widely Available

Tagged With: business ethics, ethical leadership, Ethics, Facebook, Financial Crisis, whistleblowing

Ethics on your mind? Subscribe to my ezine to get my latest article delivered right to your inbox. Click Here to Subscribe

Richard Bowen is widely known as the Citigroup whistleblower. As Business Chief Underwriter for Citigroup during the housing bubble financial crisis meltdown, he repeatedly warned Citi executive management and the board about fraudulent behavior within the organization. The company certified poor mortgages as quality mortgages and sold them to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and other investors.

Related Posts

  • Brigham Young University: Practicing What They PreachBrigham Young University: Practicing What They Preach
  • The Con Docuseries More Widely AvailableThe Con Docuseries More Widely Available
  • Ethics in the Last and Next Financial CrisisEthics in the Last and Next Financial Crisis
  • Transparency, Integrity and the Institute of Banking Irish StyleTransparency, Integrity and the Institute of Banking Irish Style

What People Are Saying About Richard M. Bowen

William D. Cohan"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst."

~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
2017-06-30T10:08:59-05:00
"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst." ~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/2556/

Eileen McDonnell"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger."

~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
2015-02-13T19:51:19-06:00
"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger." ~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/711/

Ben Stein"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero."

~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
2015-02-13T19:50:26-06:00
"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero." ~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/712/

Jim Farrell"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership."

~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
2014-12-28T19:48:17-06:00
"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership." ~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/532/

Dennis McCuistion"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years."

~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
2014-12-28T19:48:06-06:00
"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years." ~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/533/

Betty Garrett"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!"

~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
2014-12-28T19:47:50-06:00
"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!" ~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/531/

fred-timmons"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences."

~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
2014-12-28T19:47:22-06:00
"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences." ~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/530/

Presentation Topics

Playing for High Stakes: The Principles and Practice of Ethical Leadership

Dark Citi: The Story of a Whistleblower

Want to Hire Richard?

Watch Richard

See What Clients are Saying

About Richard

Recent Posts

  • What should you do before you report wrongdoing?
  • Peace and happiness this holiday season
  • Wishing you a warm and happy Thanksgiving
  • Speaking at the University of North Texas
  • Resisting Corporate and Government Corruption

Categories

  • Business Ethics
  • Congress
  • Corporate Debt
  • Corruption
  • Ethical Leadership
  • Financial Crime
  • Financial Crisis
  • Financial Crisis of 2008
  • Fraud
  • Holiday
  • International
  • Mortgage Lending
  • Mortgage Meltdown
  • Relationships
  • Resources
  • Speaking
  • Texas Politics
  • The Fed
  • Too Big To Fail
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Wall Street
  • Whistle Blowers

About Richard

Now an ethical leadership speaker, Richard Bowen was Citigroup's Business Chief Underwriter during the housing bubble.

Read more

Connect with Richard

  Facebook   Twitter   Linked   YouTube

Contact Us

Phone: +1-214-604-5492

Email: Richard@RichardMBowen.com

Contact Richard

Copyright 2021© 2023 · Richard M. Bowen | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

X
Sign up to receive my blog posts via email!
Subscribe >>