Richard Bowen

  • Home
  • About
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Media/Press
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • +1-214-604-5492

June 29, 2017 By Richard Bowen

Are Clawbacks and Shareholder Proposals Essential to Corporate Governance?

The recent Wells Fargo financial misdoings situation has focused much-needed attention once again on clawbacks, the forced return of pay and stock grants, and shareholders involvement in corporate guidance policies. The Wells Fargo’s board voted to claw back an additional $75 million in compensation from the bank’s former chief executive, John G. Stumpf, and its former head of community banking, Carrie L. Tolstedt. 

Apparently, the warning signs could be traced back at least to 2004, the investigators said. Ms. Tolstedt, who ran the national network of Wells Fargo branches, set up ruthless sales goals that even she acknowledged were unreachable. Mr. Stumpf, who had a long and trusting relationship with Ms. Tolstedt, left her on her own to run her department, the investigators said in the scathing 113-page report

The clawbacks, totalling $135 million, which to date are the largest in banking history and among the largest in corporate America has triggered some debate on how these clawback policies originate and are disclosed and enforced.

According to a Harvard Law School article on corporate governance, only about 25% of publicly traded companies have publicly disclosed recovery policies and despite studies reflecting hundreds of financial restatements among those 25%, there have been only a few clawbacks required by directors. Those company’s policies generally allowed the boards of directors to recover executive pay resulting from misconduct or materially inaccurate financial statements or performance measures, but the boards were obviously extremely reluctant to enforce those recoveries.

Wells Fargo had such a general policy until 2013, when a shareholder proposal requested a broader policy which, according to Gretchen Morgenson of the New York Times “… would require (emphasis mine) it to recoup pay from executives whose conduct caused financial or reputational harm to the company. The suggested policy also stated that recoveries would not be limited to those who committed the misdeeds; they would also reach up the line to superiors.” The board of directors implemented the policy, thus it was not voted on by the shareholders.

And, in another interesting twist, the article further notes the shareholder proposal resulting in the Wells Fargo expanded clawback policy would not have been permitted if the Financial Choice Act, the deregulatory bill that passed in the House of Representatives on June 8, had been law in 2013. 

The Financial Choice Act limits the ability of shareholders to submit proposals, by placing severe restrictions on who can make such a request. Under the Fair Choice Act, a shareholder has to own at least 1 percent of a company’s shares for three years to get a proposal on a proxy ballot. Currently, an investor must only own $2,000 worth of stock for a year or more. A large corporation may have billions of shares. The 1% rule means a heck of a lot of shares have to be owned by one shareholder in order to submit proxy proposals, and the Wells Fargo proposal would not have met this test.

So the Financial Choice Act could serve to restrict a small investor’s abilities to propose policies and actions on what they perceive as right for the company overall.

The 1 percent threshold implies that ideas submitted by smaller shareholders are less effective or successful. However, research shows differently. A new academic study confirms the role that small shareholders can play in shaping corporate behavior. It shows that large investors often embrace the policy corrections proposed by smaller shareholders.

The paper, titled “What Else Do Shareholders Want? Shareholder Proposals Contested by Firm Management,” is by three academics at the Harvard Business School: Eugene Soltes, an associate professor of business administration; Suraj Srinivasan, a professor in accounting and management; and Rajesh Vijayaraghavan, a doctoral student. They studied nearly 5,000 shareholder proposals submitted from 2003 through 2015 that corporate managers had sought to suppress by excluding them from the agenda items investors would be voting on.

Mr. Soltes says, “Obviously, there are some frivolous proposals issued by some small shareholders,” he said. But “the idea that bigger shareholders create ‘better’ proposals is not supported by empirical data.”

More broadly, the study points to why the Fair Choice Act, which aims to reduce financial regulation, focused on shareholder proposals. It concluded that “managers often seek to avoid the implementation of legitimate shareholder interests” and that larger companies with worse performance and fewer institutional investors are more likely to contest shareholder proposals.

Although the SEC is considering additional executive clawback actions allowed under Dodd-Frank, the SEC’s enforcement of the clawback provisions granted to it under Sarbanes-Oxley has been abysmal during the first decade since SOX was passed.

Thus all stakeholders, including customers, investors and employees, must rely primarily upon corporate boards to adopt and enforce prudent corporate governance policies and ensure executive accountability. And shareholder feedback, including the ability of small shareholders to submit proposals, is essential to board accountability to maintain those corporate governance safeguards.

Related Posts

  • Banking In the 21st Century: The Great American Ponzi Scheme at Wells Fargo (and all TBTF)
  • The Saga of Wells Fargo – Are Banks Reaping What They Sow?
  • All This Misbehavior and No One Is Guilty!

Respected Business Leaders Call Out for Ethics and Accountability!
FED UP… An Insider’s Take On Why The Federal Reserve Is Bad For America
Ethics on your mind? Subscribe to my ezine to get my latest article delivered right to your inbox. Click Here to Subscribe

Richard Bowen is widely known as the Citigroup whistleblower. As Business Chief Underwriter for Citigroup during the housing bubble financial crisis meltdown, he repeatedly warned Citi executive management and the board about fraudulent behavior within the organization. The company certified poor mortgages as quality mortgages and sold them to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and other investors.

Related Posts

  • The Men Who Stole the World (and got away with it)The Men Who Stole the World (and got away with it)
  • Celebrating Ethics … A Way of LifeCelebrating Ethics … A Way of Life
  • Is Fraud in the Eye of the Beholder? Andy Fastow ExplainsIs Fraud in the Eye of the Beholder? Andy Fastow Explains
  • Singing the Varsity BluesSinging the Varsity Blues

What People Are Saying About Richard M. Bowen

William D. Cohan"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst."

~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
2017-06-30T10:08:59-05:00
"Richard Bowen is one of my heroes. His is a story of human fortitude at its best and Wall Street at its worst." ~ William D. Cohan, NY Times Best Selling Author
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/2556/

Eileen McDonnell"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger."

~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
2015-02-13T19:51:19-06:00
"Richard Bowen reinforced my motto that "there is no right way to do a wrong thing.” Long after his presentation, the conversation has continued about personal responsibility and the courage to challenge things that appear to be wrong. We encourage this dialog and rely on it to help make our business stronger." ~ Eileen McDonnell, Chairman, CEO, & President, Penn Mutual
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/711/

Ben Stein"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero."

~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
2015-02-13T19:50:26-06:00
"Richard Bowen, you are a star and a hero." ~ Ben Stein, Economist and Political Commentator
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/712/

Jim Farrell"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership."

~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
2014-12-28T19:48:17-06:00
"Richard's speech at the April Financial Executives International dinner was informative, interesting, riveting, and fast moving.  The feedback from members was overwhelming positive, and Richard received one of the few standing ovations given by our membership." ~ Jim Farrell, Program Chairman, Dallas Chapter, Financial Executives International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/532/

Dennis McCuistion"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years."

~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
2014-12-28T19:48:06-06:00
"Richard Bowen has been there, done that, and has the scars to prove it, and his message of corruption at the highest levels of industry and government needs to be heard. I only wish that more bankers had the courage that Bowen exhibits. He is not only one of the most talented bankers I have ever met, he has more integrity than all the bankers on Wall Street put together. If his former employer had listened to him taxpayers would not have had to bail out Citi for the third time in the last 30 years." ~ Dennis McCuistion, Host of the McCuistion TV program
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/533/

Betty Garrett"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!"

~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
2014-12-28T19:47:50-06:00
"Richard Bowen is a dynamic, entertaining speaker and story-teller - a CPA with a great personality!" ~ Betty Garrett, Garrett Speakers International
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/531/

fred-timmons"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences."

~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
2014-12-28T19:47:22-06:00
"I believe Richard Bowen is the only keynote speaker to ever receive a standing ovation from the Texas Society of CPA’s at any of its annual conferences." ~ Fred Timmons, Chairman of The Texas Society of CPA's
https://richardmbowen.com/testimonials/530/

Presentation Topics

Playing for High Stakes: The Principles and Practice of Ethical Leadership

Dark Citi: The Story of a Whistleblower

Want to Hire Richard?

Watch Richard

See What Clients are Saying

About Richard

Recent Posts

  • Warmest thoughts and best wishes for a wonderful and safe holiday
  • Thanksgiving 2020
  • Pausing For A While
  • The world is in crisis
  • Relationships Count

Categories

  • Business Ethics
  • Congress
  • Corporate Debt
  • Corruption
  • Ethical Leadership
  • Financial Crime
  • Financial Crisis
  • Financial Crisis of 2008
  • Holiday
  • International
  • Mortgage Lending
  • Mortgage Meltdown
  • Relationships
  • Texas Politics
  • The Fed
  • Too Big To Fail
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates
  • Wall Street
  • Whistle Blowers

About Richard

Now an ethical leadership speaker, Richard Bowen was Citigroup's Business Chief Underwriter during the housing bubble.

Read more

Connect with Richard

  Facebook   Twitter   Linked   Google Plus   YouTube

Contact Us

Phone: +1-214-604-5492

Email: Richard@RichardMBowen.com

Contact Richard
Google+

Copyright 2019© 2021 · Richard M. Bowen | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

SAVE & ACCEPT
X
Sign up to receive my blog posts via email!
Subscribe >>